The United States, particularly the state of New York, recently banned the Chinese artificial intelligence assistant DeepSeek from government devices. The decision, announced by Governor Kathy Hochul, was driven by concerns over national security, censorship, and the risk of foreign surveillance. This move is part of a broader effort by the U.S. to safeguard data privacy and prevent potential espionage by foreign entities.
What Is DeepSeek and Why Is It Controversial?
DeepSeek is an AI assistant developed by a Chinese research lab owned by the hedge fund High-Flyer. In January 2025, it gained massive popularity, becoming the most downloaded app on the Apple App Store, surpassing OpenAI’s ChatGPT. While its success highlighted China’s rapid advancements in AI, it also raised alarms in the U.S. due to the following concerns:
- Potential Censorship and Data Security Risks – Analysts believe DeepSeek may censor information based on the Chinese government’s directives. Additionally, U.S. officials worry that user data collected by the app could be accessed by Chinese authorities under China’s intelligence laws.
- Surveillance Fears – Chinese law requires companies to assist in national intelligence work if asked. This has led to fears that DeepSeek could be used to gather sensitive data, particularly from government devices and businesses.
- Economic and Technological Competition – The success of DeepSeek triggered concerns in Silicon Valley, as it claimed to outperform some leading U.S. AI models at a fraction of the cost. The rapid rise of Chinese AI dominance has caused unease among U.S. tech firms and policymakers alike.
Government Response: National Security Over Convenience
Governor Hochul’s directive banning DeepSeek on New York government devices aligns with the Legislative Oversight of Automated Decision-making in Government Act (LOADinG Act), which enforces transparency and risk assessment for AI usage in state agencies. The move aims to prevent potential threats from foreign AI applications.
Beyond New York, federal lawmakers have also taken action:
- Bipartisan Legislation – Congress introduced a bill to ban DeepSeek from all federal government devices due to espionage risks.
- Proposed Nationwide Ban – Senator Josh Hawley has pushed for a complete ban on Americans downloading Chinese AI models, citing national security concerns.
A Repeat of the TikTok Debate?
The DeepSeek controversy mirrors the ongoing battle over TikTok, owned by ByteDance, another China-based company. The U.S. has long expressed concerns that TikTok could share American user data with the Chinese government, leading to attempts to ban or regulate the platform. While China denies these allegations, U.S. lawmakers remain skeptical about the security risks posed by Chinese technology.
What’s Next?
The U.S.-China tech rivalry continues to intensify, with AI being the latest battleground. As AI tools become more advanced and widely used, governments will likely impose stricter regulations to control data security risks. Moreover, the DeepSeek ban may set a precedent for future restrictions on foreign AI applications in the U.S.
The question remains: Will the U.S. completely block Chinese AI apps from its digital ecosystem, or will there be room for cooperation in the future? For now, national security concerns take priority, making it clear that the U.S. is not willing to take chances with foreign AI dominance.